You are viewing [info]malderor's journal

 
 
24 January 2006 @ 04:15 pm
Not so Fantastic.  
I'b sick. I hab a code.

I was too sickly last night to accomplish much besides ordering up some spicy thai soup from across the street, and watching the Fantastic Four. I'd heard FF pretty much sucked, but never bothered to bounce it out of my Netflix queue.

It pretty much sucked, but it was all my embattled immune system could keep up with. The whole Johnny Storm "extreme sports guy" subplot was offensively irritating. But my main gripe was a general soullessness of the film in general. I just didn't really care about the heroes, the villain, or anything much at all. (Again, it may have been the germs.)

Interestingly, they seem to have had some problems with the special effects used for Mr. Fantastic's stretchy-abilities. The Human Torch's fire stuff looks great. The Invisible Girl's powers are conveyed in a fairly understandable fashion. And the Thing looks like a guy in a rubber suit, because he is. But almost every shot of Mr. Fantastic stretching happens just off screen, or else they cut into the shot just as he's finishing or something. My guess is the stretchy-effects looked totally hokey, and they cut around it. Just a guess, though, based on some clunky editorial choices. It's odd that fire is easier to fake than stretchiness.

Probably the biggest reason I rented the movie, though, was because Ioan Gruffudd plays Reed Richards, and he was great in the Hornblower Series on A&E. If you're a fan of the Sharpe's series with Sean Bean, or of the Patrick O'Brian books, then you should definitely check out the Hornblower movies. All are available from Netflix, and Gruffudd is really good in them. Good enough that I watched a fairly crappy movie last night, hoping he'd salvage it.

Steve
 
 
Current Music: The Jesus & Mary Chain - The Complete BBC Sessions
 
 
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )
firesarah[info]firesarah on January 25th, 2006 02:06 pm (UTC)
F4 = Unmovie
Yeah, it royally sucks. It's in the new line of comic/movies where the plot is so thin and they spend all their money on the FX. I would venture the reason you didn't like the characters were because they had no character. I would add to this the Spiderman movies, the one about the guy who's a demon and lives in the subway and smokes a cigar and the Xmen movies. These aren't movies that will last, and they're not meant to. They're $150MM disposable celluloid.
malderor[info]malderor on January 25th, 2006 10:41 pm (UTC)
Re: F4 = Unmovie
You forgot Constantine and Daredevil, two of the lesser examples of the genre.

It's very disappointing to me, as a (somewhat) former comic book geek. They finally have the effects-technology to tell some of the great stories from comic books, and to make them actually look decent. (As opposed to, say, the Lou Ferrigno years.) And there are some great epic stories just sitting there in comic book world, waiting to be told.

But in the main, most comic movies have sucked the wang. (Don't get me started on how bad the first Batman movie sucked. Trust me, you won't like me when I'm angry.) I'm not sure what exactly is missing, but they need to do something other than make these movies look like expensive episodes of Deep Space Nine. (Seriously, the sets in these things tend to be way too sanitized and artificial-looking.)

I think The X-Men 2 and Hellboy were actually the best of the lot, and they relied way too much on big special effects sequences. But the root of the problem may be that the films just aren't that interestingly shot or directed to begin with. There was certainly no 'edge' to the X-Men or Fantastic Four. Remember how cool The Matrix looked when it first came out? Somebody needs to make that kind of cinematic leap with a comic book movie, before they run out of titles*.

Steve
*I should mention I haven't seen the second two Blade movies, and I don't know how they are. But I never read that comic either.
ladymsruby[info]ladymsruby on January 25th, 2006 06:56 pm (UTC)
OMG - Horatio Hornblower. I saw those - an old boyfriend was obsessed with that show and I was forced to suffer through, and then became a convert. They are great.
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )